A multi-agency search for two missing South Bend women shifted into a death investigation on Tuesday after a submerged Jeep Grand Cherokee was pulled from the St. Joseph River in Niles. Authorities recovered two bodies from the vehicle, ending a two-day search that began when 23-year-old Alexandra Navarro and 24-year-old Vanessa Bautista failed to return home Sunday morning.
The recovery site sits along a wooded bend of the St. Joseph River where the roadway runs close to a steep drop-off. Emergency crews responded to the scene Tuesday after searchers identified tire marks and signs of disturbed brush along the embankment. Tow trucks and dive units spent hours securing the SUV before pulling it from the water.

Niles Police Chief James Millin confirmed that the vehicle recovered matched the Jeep driven by the missing women. Inside, officers found two individuals wearing clothing identical to the items described in the initial missing-persons report. Detectives immediately sealed the area as a crime scene while state and local investigators began documenting evidence around the bank.
Navarro and Bautista were last seen alive during the early hours of Sunday, September 13. According to South Bend police records, the two friends had been in Elkhart before heading toward Niles. Cellular data and last-known phone pings helped officers narrow their focus to the river corridor running through Berrien County.
Investigators have not yet established what caused the Jeep to leave the roadway and plunge over the bank into the river. Police are analyzing speed, weather conditions, and potential mechanical issues that might explain the crash. Detectives are also examining whether another vehicle was involved or if any external factors played a role in the incident.
The Berrien County Medical Examiner’s Office is conducting full autopsies to determine the official cause and manner of death for both individuals. Chief Millin noted that until medical examiners complete formal DNA or dental comparisons, police cannot issue an official confirmation of identity. However, officers have briefed both families on the findings at the scene.
The discovery has sent shockwaves through both South Bend and Niles, where community members spent days sharing flyers and searching local roads. Relatives now await the medical examiner’s final report as investigators work to reconstruct the final timeline. For now, the focus remains on finding out how a routine trip ended in the waters of the St. Joseph River.



